Thursday 8 September 2011

The Logic Book, M. Bergmann, J. Moor, J. Nelson, McGraw Hill, 2004, 10.6E, 2(c), p. 572

The task - to show that the argument is valid:
  1. (z)[Gz ⊃(y)(Ky ⊃ Hzy)]
  2. (Ki • Gj) • i = j
  3. ∴ Hii
  4. Gj ......... 2 Simp.
  5. Gj ⊃(y)(Ky ⊃ Hjy) ......... 1 UI z/j
  6. (y)(Ky ⊃ Hjy) ......... 4,5 MP
  7. Ki ......... 2 Simp.
  8. Ki ⊃Hji ......... 6 UI y/i
  9. Hji ......... 7,8 MP
  10. i = j ......... 2 Simp.
  11. Hii ......... 9,10 Id

No comments:

Post a Comment